
Often doctors and medical professionals wind up treating symptoms. It’s quicker and cheaper in the short run to do so. Why run all sorts of shotgun tests when some symptom (s) fit a common diagnosis? Cut to the first exit and get on with the next patient, right? The old saying goes ‘if you hear hoofbeats, you think horses first not zebras’. But it’s not just a practice in medicine. Car mechanics and plumbers and electricians also fall into the same trap in search of the quick, efficient, cheap fix. Initially it is what the customer wants as well… most, but not all of the time.
I was reminded of this unavoidable trap recently. My wife and I had noticed dust and staining coming from the base trim in our master bathroom. Even after a thorough cleaning, reddish-brown spots would appear next to the baseboard. Many local folks had told us that is was not a question of IF but WHEN one would have termite infestation here in the Sonoran Desert. These blind insects like the warm weather and easy access to stucco-covered wood that contacts the soil. Apparently our water closet baseboard was simply irresistible to these wood sucking larvae. I imagined the squishy feet of millions of termites marching behind the drywall.

Well, the painted and caulked trim wood was soft to the touch all around the walls nearest the toilet. I finally called the termite man for a closer inspection. To our surprise he suggested that the “evidence” we assumed was termite related was actually caused by the long term presence of water. No leaks were apparent, but we would have to remove the base trim and some drywall to be sure. The next day I pulled out the pry bar, chisels and mallet to remove the deteriorating trim, all the while running cost estimates in my mind. This was going to be expensive, I worried, like very expensive.
I was shocked to find black decay on the unpainted side of the trim boards. The base plate and wall studs were so saturated that they appeared to be black. My symptoms were being stripped away to reveal causes. Yes, the walls closest to the toilet were wet, but it was not clear yet where the leak originated. I cleaned up the mess and called a plumber, wondering the entire time about rotting studs, renovation costs, and black mold. This could be expensive and unhealthy. I was past treating symptoms. I needed the cure.

The next day our very smart plumber thoroughly checked things out. He determined that the incoming pipes were not leaking and offered his theory that the wax ring below the toilet needed to be replaced. He pointed out that the previous homeowner had totally caulked the toilet to the tile floor, suggesting that the symptoms had been treated in the classic cheap and quick method. Since we bought the house four years ago, I surmised that the seepage had at a least five year head start on our discovery. Due to the risk of dangerous mold, Justin the plumber called in a trusted renovation company, Steamy Concepts, which sounds like a strip club downtown near the airport.

Later that same day Jason showed up with a cool device that could see through walls and identify heat spots. His technological advantage merely confirmed Justin’s theory– the leak came from the output of the toilet; somehow moisture wicked through the mortar holding the tile in place, and found its way into the base of the walls. Jason explained that our issue should be covered by our homeowner’s insurance, and he began to file a claim. My relief was threatened by anxiety about the fact that we were leaving on a ten day cruise to Alaska two days hence. Could it be remediated in that time frame? We had a dog sitter scheduled to arrive as we left. Would the air be safe to breathe? Jason rolled in a big dehumidifier and an air scrubber to dry and clean the space.
Well, our case was prioritized. On Saturday Christian came by to cut out and treat the affected wood. I was pleased to see that much of what had appeared to be mold was now dry wood with just a patina of bacterial growth on it. Whew, no reconstruction needed, just a bleach solution. Except for the noise and heat generated by the two machines in our water closet, we felt reassured… until the air conditioning crapped out. Like the toilet, our a/c system was old. Now it seemed like a race for us.

We called our trusted A/C guy Jacob. He agreed to come out first thing on Monday, the day we were leaving for Vancouver. I scrambled around YouTube trying to find any way to treat the symptoms and get our A/C to limp through the next two weeks. I was sweating mentally and physically as I learned about capacitors and compressor motor fans. Why, why, why? The bathroom wax ring was a five dollar item at Home Depot that I could have replaced. The capacitor was a twenty dollar item on Amazon that I was likewise confident I could replace. However, tickling the symptoms instead of curing the causes had put us in a pressurized pickle barrel.

Instead of routine maintenance we were looking at major surgery while we floated through the inside passage of Alaska, two thousand miles away without reliable cell service. How would this cross fire hurricane end? The dog sitter was new. If the A/C couldn’t keep up with the blistering late summer heat, she could not stay at our house. Who would let the workmen in and out of our house? Would our insurance cover any part of the costs? What would we have to face in eleven days?
As it turned out our insurance covered the bathroom debacle, minus our $1,000 deductible. Then they promptly dropped our coverage. Seems like insurance is a great idea until you actually need to use it. I finished the reconstruction for about $400 in materials. Cost to me was an aching back for three days, but I was pleased with the results, using large ceramic tiles instead of just drywall to close up the damaged walls. Whew! Symptoms are not equivalent to causes. Ideally they are smoke signals warning of impending fires ahead. Symptom treatment is rarely satisfying since there is no conclusive evidence that such treatment works, whereas fixing the cause of symptoms is self-evident and reassuring at the same time. Ahhh, it’s safe to go to the potty again.
In the mental health arena it is the same way. Medication alone, like caulk and paint on wet wood, can relieve symptoms of anxiety and depression and all of their cousin diagnoses. Yet such fixes are usually just surface treatments to keep up appearances. I won’t go any further into the parallels of leaking toilets and leaking patients. Let’s just conclude that simply nodding and medicating hurting folks allows their causes to fester and rot behind fragile veneers. It is much harder and frustrating to dig past the rot to their good foundations, resolve the causes and rebuild.

So there it is: another dumpster fire extinguished in time for the next ill fated star crossing.
























:quality(70)/arc-anglerfish-arc2-prod-tronc.s3.amazonaws.com/public/OFBHA4YON54HLAKCJPOEATDXFU.jpg)










